Are you dreaming of a vacation where crystal-clear waters meet lush, tropical landscapes and you get to unwind in a cozy, private retreat? Then pack your bags (don’t forget the sunscreen) because Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage on St. Thomas is calling your name!
Let’s be honest: choosing the right vacation rental is just as important as choosing the right destination. You can’t experience St. Thomas’ beauty if you’re stuck in a dull, uncomfortable place, right? Lucky for you, Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage offers everything you need to make your getaway one for the books. Here’s why it’s the best vacation rental on St. Thomas and why it’s perfect for your next trip.
A Dream Property in Paradise
First things first: the cottage itself is stunning. Steve and Amie Mayes, the owners, fell in love with the property during a leap of faith purchase in 2020—without even seeing it in person! But thanks to Amie’s 25+ years in the hospitality industry and Steve’s DIY skills, they’ve turned it into an island oasis that’s everything you could hope for (and more). From the cozy cottage to the beautiful pool and fully stocked tiki bar, everything has been carefully crafted to ensure your stay is nothing short of perfection.
Amie, with her background in Hilton Hotels, and Steve, the handy-man extraordinaire, have worked tirelessly to make sure every inch of Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage feels like home—but with way better views! If the idea of having everything you need (and more) on hand sounds like your kind of vacation, then keep reading. You have never stayed at an AirBnB like this before. THE absolute most unique and fun property on St Thomas. Every detail has been thought of.
Picture-Perfect Views

WOW! Sit and relax right outside your cottage and enjoy the views of Hull Bay on the Northside of St Thomas.
Imagine waking up to panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean, Hull Bay, and the Outer and Inner Brass islands. It sounds like something out of a dream, right? At Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage, these views are a reality. Whether you’re enjoying your morning coffee on the large private deck or watching surfers catch some waves from your balcony, the scenery is unbeatable.
And don’t even get us started on the sunsets! If you’re lucky enough to visit during the summer months, get ready for vibrant skies filled with pinks, purples, and oranges. Trust us, it’s a view you’ll never forget.
Luxury and Comfort, Island Style

The pool is just the right size for 1-4 people at Two Tickets to Paradise Cottage. You can watch tv at the bar from the pool or listen to your own tunes on the surround sound system at the tiki bar.
Now let’s talk about comfort. Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage is the perfect balance of cozy and luxurious. The cottage is air-conditioned (from 8 pm to 8 am) and comes with a comfy queen bed—perfect for relaxing after a day of exploring the island. Whether you’re cooking a meal in the fully stocked kitchen or taking a leisurely nap in the hammock chair, every detail has been thought out to make your stay as comfortable as possible.
Need to cool off? The cottage comes with a fantastic saltwater pool, recently renovated with decorative turtle tiles and a pool heater (by request @ +$). Whether you want to sunbathe by the pool or relax in the shade of the cabana, this spot is the ideal place to unwind and soak in the tropical vibes. And, for those who enjoy a little fun with their relaxation, you’ll have your own private tiki bar to mix up a cocktail or two (or three).
Everything You Need, Right Here
What makes Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage stand out as the best vacation rental on St. Thomas is the sheer number of thoughtful amenities provided for guests. You won’t need to bring much—everything from beach towels to cooler bags is ready for you. You’ll even receive two stainless steel cups (which are yours to keep!) to make sure you stay hydrated and stylish during your island adventures.
And don’t forget about the honor bar—fully stocked with all your favorite island beverages and ready for you to enjoy. Not to mention the awesome gas grill and pizza oven, perfect for enjoying a casual meal in your own private paradise. Don’t forget about the air fryer and blender.
Professionally Cleaned Between Every Guest Stay
At Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage on St. Thomas, we hold ourselves to an exceptional standard of cleanliness. Thanks to Amie’s decades of hospitality experience with Hilton, our approach goes well beyond what you’ll find in the average vacation rental. Every detail is meticulously cared for, and after each guest, the entire space is thoroughly cleaned and sanitized —including the bedspread, not just the linens. When you stay with us, you can count on a spotless, hotel-quality experience with the comfort and charm of a private island retreat.
Want to Bring Friends? No Problem!
Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage was designed with couples in mind, but if you’re traveling with another couple (or even friends), there’s plenty of room to accommodate. The additional bedroom and bathroom are perfect for another couple, with a queen-size bed and a fully renovated bathroom. This makes it easy to bring extra friends or family along without sacrificing any privacy or comfort.
A Location You Can’t Beat
While the property itself is the perfect getaway, you’re also just minutes away from some of St. Thomas’ best restaurants, bars, and local spots. The Shack @ Hull Bay is a short 2-minute drive away, offering fresh fish tacos and drinks with a laid-back beach atmosphere. And if you’re in the mood for something new, check out Fish Bar—a spot just a 3-minute walk from the cottage. If you’re a seafoodie then you have to check it out.
Plus, with easy access to local tours and boat rentals (courtesy of Steve and Amie’s island connections), you’ll have plenty of exciting things to do during your stay.
Get Ready to Book Your Stay!
Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, a relaxing retreat, or a little bit of both, Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage has everything you need to enjoy your stay on St. Thomas. With breathtaking views, luxurious amenities, and a perfect location, it’s no wonder that this property is quickly becoming known as the best vacation rental on St. Thomas.
Ready to make paradise your reality? Visit our reservations page to book your stay today! You’re just a few clicks away from making unforgettable memories at Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage.
Compare Two Tickets to the average
AirBnb Vacation Rental on St Thomas, VI

Recent Comments