If you’re planning a trip to St. Thomas, one of the best ways to explore the island is by renting a car. Sure, you could rely on taxis or the local safari buses, but if you want the freedom to explore at your own pace, renting a car is the way to go. From stunning beaches to hidden gems, having your own vehicle makes it so much easier to see everything St. Thomas has to offer.
At Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage, we highly recommend renting a car to make the most of your stay. And when you’re ready to book your vacation rental, don’t forget to book direct with us to save money and enjoy exclusive perks!
Why You Should Rent a Car in St. Thomas
St. Thomas is only 32 square miles, but trust us—it’s not walkable. The island is full of steep hills, winding roads, and breathtaking overlooks, so unless you plan on getting a workout in every time you leave the beach, a rental car is the best option.
1. Explore Off-the-Beaten-Path Beaches
Some of the best beaches in St. Thomas—like Lindquist Beach and Hull Bay—are nowhere near taxi routes. With a rental car, you can visit these stunning, lesser-known spots on your own schedule.
2. Save Money on Transportation
Taxis in St. Thomas charge per person, not per ride, so costs add up quickly—especially if you’re traveling with family or a group. Renting a car is often cheaper than relying on taxis.
3. Experience the Island Like a Local
Want to find the best roadside food stands? Need to make a quick stop at a local market? With your own car, you can discover the island’s hidden gems at your own pace.
Top 5 Car Rental Companies in St. Thomas VI
To make things easier, we’ve compiled a list of reputable car rental companies on the island. These options offer a great selection of vehicles, from compact cars to Jeeps perfect for island driving.
1. Paradise Car Rental (Facebook)
✅ Locally owned and operated ✅ Wide selection of Jeeps and SUVs ✅ Excellent customer service and flexible pickup options
2. Discount Car Rental (Website)
✅ Competitive pricing ✅ Free pickup and drop-off service ✅ Family-owned with great reviews
3. Dependable Car Rental (Website)
✅ Conveniently located near the airport ✅ Well-maintained vehicles ✅ Friendly and efficient service
4. Budget Rent A Car (Website)
✅ Recognizable brand with a solid reputation ✅ Multiple locations across the island ✅ Good selection of economy and luxury vehicles
5. Amalie Car Rental (Website)
✅ Airport pickup and drop-off available ✅ Great for long-term rentals ✅ Newer vehicles with modern features
Tips for Driving in St. Thomas
Driving in St. Thomas is an adventure, but don’t worry—it’s totally doable if you keep these tips in mind:
Drive on the Left – Unlike the mainland U.S., we drive on the left side of the road in St. Thomas. It takes some getting used to, but you’ll catch on quickly!
⛰️ Expect Steep Hills & Sharp Turns – The roads here are winding and hilly, so take it slow and enjoy the scenery.
⛽ Gas Up When You Can – Gas stations aren’t on every corner like in the States. If you see one and you’re running low, stop and fill up!
Use Google Maps, but Double-Check Directions – While Google Maps is generally reliable, it sometimes takes you on scenic “shortcuts” that are more adventure than convenience. When in doubt, ask a local!
Where to Park in St. Thomas
Parking is easier than you might expect, but here are a few things to know:
️ Downtown Charlotte Amalie: Limited street parking, but paid lots are available near the waterfront.
️ Beach Parking: Most beaches have free parking, but some, like Magens Bay, charge a small entry fee.
️ Restaurants & Attractions: Many restaurants offer free parking, but check signs to be sure.
Final Thoughts – Book Your Stay & Your Car Rental!
If you’re visiting St. Thomas, VI, renting a car is the best way to explore the island’s stunning beaches, scenic drives, and local hotspots. Whether you go with Paradise Car Rental, Discount Car Rental, or one of the other great options, you’ll love the freedom to see everything the island has to offer.
And when you’re ready to book your stay, remember to book directly with Two Tickets To Paradise Cottage to save money and enjoy exclusive perks.
See you in paradise! ☀️
Recent Comments